Mr. E. wrote:
I'll try to come back tomorrow with my definitive vote, but for now, I think no one is our best choice, for top secret reasons. Sorry.
How convenient. Tell me, if it's really true that he can help us, then why is it that he isn't willing to tell us how?
We can't simply take your word for it that Evan is worth keeping alive unless you tell us why. After all, for all we know, you could be evil and trying to ally with him yourself.
I say we keep voting Evan unless he explains how he can help us.
That is completely understandable. But here's my explanation.
I have a plan. I really wish I could tell you details, but I can't. Basically, we need to lynch no one, and see what happens tonight. On the next day phase we will lynch someone. I realize I'm being really sketchy right now, but Evan is cooperating over PM(there is a good reason why he's hiding his power), and I'm confident that next day phase we can lynch a mafia. We were gonna do a no-lynch anyway today. We're really not losing much by no-lynching, and next phase we'll know a mafia. The only reason I can give you to trust me is that this is a low-risk high-reward... Thing. If I don't tell you who to lynch tomorrow, you lose another day and night(which, again, you were already planning on doing), and then you'll lynch me. So... Either I give you someone to lynch or you lynch me. Guaranteed lynch tomorrow on someone who's almost certainly mafia.
More on Evan specifically, he claims that his plan was to get as much information as possible and funnel it to me and someone else he trusted. Regardless, another effect of this plan would be to determine whether or not Evan is working with evil. Depending on what happens next night phase, I will be able to show that Evan is either trustworthy, or working with evil, in which case we can lynch his contact, and threaten him with a lynch if he doesn't do what we say. If this happens, we will have a way for Evan to easily prove himself, that will help good immensely. If he doesn't do this, we'll kill him. If he does, of course we'll still have to be wary, but he'll have helped us a lot, and it's unlikely that he'll be willing to betray us after that. Or at all, really. WE'RE THREATENING TO KILL HIM. That's literally the only thing in this game he has a reason to directly care about. He knows we're willing to kill him, and mafia probably isn't. They will want to make the most of their every kill right now, and it would be a bad decision to waste one on a neutral while we get more information.
Inquisitor is love, Inquisitor is life.
"This is how humans are: We question all our beliefs, except for the ones that we really believe in, and those we never think to question."
I have no life and Nuna is the kindest.
Dragons![Here since 7/23][Here since 7/23]